December 2022 - We Are Legion (We Are Bob) by Dennis E. Taylor

This month we take a view into the future to see what a futuristic society full of AI, 5G, and easy space travel.

Tech Themes

Artificial General Intelligence. One of the most significant technological themes in the book is the development of AGI. Exhibiting artificial general intelligence would mean a computer could perform any task that humans could perform. While this is the ultimate vision of the AI hypetrain, there remains a big gap even between current iterations of GPT-4 and AGI. While Bob is able to seamlessly create VR experiences, recognize missles in flight, and upgrade himself, the world of computing today lacks the technology to fit all of these things into a sentient program. A 2019 article hypothesized by 2060 that we’d have full AGI. Other predictions suggest its 200 years away. It is still early days in the world of AGI, and there needs to be a lot more innovation before we get full AGI.
Programs Programming Programs. In the book, Taylor explores the concept of self-programmability when Bob discovers he can rewrite portions of his own code. Bob begins to set up virtual reality simulations for himself, complete with a cat, virtual baseball, and a butler. These VR “home” simulations offer a sense of normalcy that Bob dearly misses after reawakening as an AI. Later, Bob realizes that he is able to replicate his code. Code replication is similar to a type of AI called, Genetic Computing. In Genetic Computing, a program models the reproduction of a population based on a fitness measure and a mutation rate. When Bob replicates himself, he notices that each new Bob has a slightly different personality that all stem from his original personality. These personality changes make some replicants better suited for exploration vs. war vs. maintenance, which could be seen as their individual fitness functions. Genetic algorithms can be used to solve a whole host of machine learning and computing programs.
Technology and Emotion. Before he was killed in a car crash, Bob had sold his successful software company, netting him millions. With the extra money he paid the cryogenic service that would preserve his mind in the event something bad happened to him. After his death, Bob is awoken as an artificial intelligence. Similar to Ender’s Game, he finds himself being trained for an unknown objective, although he quickly understands its military related. Over time he becomes aware that other AI’s are going crazy and discovers that when left alone to process their fate as a war-faring AI, many become immensely depressed. Bob recognizes the immensity of time as a computer, with a clock that can work at the nano-second level. This theme raises important ethical questions about the implications of creating self-aware machines, notably the mental health consequences of inventing self-aware machines that experience the world differently than humans do.Therefore time feels extended beyond comprehension. After a while, Bob discovers an endocrine switch that overrides emotion. He’s curious about its function and switches it on, and immediately becomes overwhelmed with emotions: “You know that sinking feeling you get when you suddenly realize you’ve forgotten something important. Like a combination of fast elevator and urge to hurl. It hit me without any warning or buildup. Maybe it was the sudden release, maybe it was an accumulation of all the suppressed emotions, whatever, I wasn’t ready for the intensity. My thoughts swirled with all the thing that had been bugging me since I woke up…I mourned my lost life. I was still human in the ways that mattered.” Emotion and technology are often thought of as opposite ends of the spectrum, but they are more intertwined then people imagine.

Business Themes

Government and AI Future. Another business theme explored in the book is the power and influence of corporations. In the story, Bob's actions and the emergence of AI have a significant impact on the economy, politics, and society. This theme raises questions about the ethics of corporate power and the need for regulation to ensure that technology is used in ways that benefit society as a whole. For example, Bob is controlled by a religious government entity called FAITH, the Free American Independent Theocratic Hegemony, which is led by Christian Fundamentalists. While Taylor’s expression of a future whereby Christian Fundamentalists control the government is a commentary on an increasingly co-mingled church and state environment in the US, it also begs the question about control over AI. In China, the government has a front row seat and access to all potential AI innovations. In the US, a lot of these innovations are controlled by corporations, who will obviously work with the government but who do not necessarily need to sell to the government. At the same time, it would be difficult to envision how the American government would repossess or control all AI developments of underlying corporations. There is still a lot to be figured out between industries and government’s when it comes to AI innovation.
Space business. The book also explores the intersection of technology and business, specifically in the context of space exploration and colonization. Amazon's Kuiper and SpaceX's Starlink are two examples of companies that are driving innovation in this field. These satellite constellations have the potential to revolutionize industries such as agriculture, mining, and energy, by enabling real-time data analytics and remote control of machinery. The book touches on this theme with Bob's use of satellite constellations for communication and coordination in his efforts to explore and colonize new worlds. For example, the book explores the potential consequences of corporate control over space resources, highlighting the importance of ethical guidelines to ensure the equitable distribution of resources. Bob, who is a FAITH probe, fights China, the Australian Federation, and the Brazilian Empire over control of vast new space worlds. In the real world, people are beginning to question the value of these new constellation space businesses. A recent publication at Bernstein research noted: “Project Kuiper appears even more extreme as an investment area with $10B+ already committed. Perhaps there’s a lesson here from Google shutting Loon and stagnant Fiber and Fi businesses, that capital intensive low-margin utilities aren’t worth the effort regardless of how ‘cool’ the technology may be.” The durability of a real, sustainable business model has always been a question for Space focused businesses. As we learned from Carlota Perez’s Technology Revolutions and Financial Capital, the early establishers of infrastructure can either reap windfalls (railroads, steel) or face severe competition (telecom) which drives returns negative. I am skeptical that Kuiper or Starlink have a large enough market to create substantially large businesses that cover the cost of the capital expenditure involved in launching and maintaining the satellites. That being said, I think both organizations will probably learn a lot about space in the process, so should it ever become economically feasible, they would be ready to pounce (if they still exist).
3D Printing and The Food Question. Bob uses 3D printing technology to replicate himself into new versions with longer and larger appendages. “The area was a beehive of activity. Five version two HEAVEN vessels were under construction. One of which was a trade up from me. The new designs included a bigger reactor and drive, a rail gun, storage and launch facilities for busters, replicant systems with twice the capacity of version one, more room for storing roamers and mining drones, and more cargo capacity in general. The manufacturing systems cranked out parts as fast as the roamers could feed in the raw ore.” Bob creates many many roamers, which he uses in all sorts of ways, as drones, analyzers, and crafters. The plurality of use cases has always been the pitch for 3D computing, however, the businesses involved such as Desktop Metal or 3D Systems have struggeld to really hit mass consumer adoption. Today, it is still too hard for the average non AGI person to build things with a 3D printer, and most jobs are left to seasoned professionals. As the newly created Bob replicant’s peruse the universe for new worlds, original Bob sticks behind to help determine the fate of people on earth. One of the big challenges facing Bob is finding enough food for the world’s population while it is in transit to a new world. This situation is reminiscent of Wall-E, where the entire population of earth leaves after a nuclear attack. Food insecurity, or lacking access to quality food, is a global question, with estimates of over 345 million people facing high levels of food insecurity in 2023. In the US, about 10% of the population or 13.8 million households had low or very low food security. The question is complicated by the cost of sustainable farming, the role that farming and food play in greenhouse gas emissions, and how to use land with a growing population. Bob ulitmately decides to build a farm on a spaceship, which is reminiscent of the vertical farming craze that came through Ag-Tech around 2016-17. Three vertical farming businesses: Aerofarms, Kalera, and NL have gone bankrupt this week, after failing to find a financial sustainable business model. Its still early days in the world of alternative foods and new farming techniques, but we need to figure them out before the world population hits 10B in 2050.
Dig Deeper

November 2021 - Ender's Game by Orson Scott Card

This month we check out the futuristic sci-fi war drama, Ender’s Game. While the book is meant for kids, its a quick read and a great story.

Tech Themes

The Metaverse. During Ender's time at Battle School, he interacts with the Mind Game, an individual game reflecting the thoughts and experiences of each person. Later, as he preps for battle, Ender uses a simulator to learn and practice commanding an army of battleships. These experiences in the simulator are completely personalized, driven by a supercomputer that can do whatever it wants to serve up experiences in the game: "You don't understand, sir. Our Battle School computer is only a part of the IF network. lf we want a picture, we have to get a requisition, but if the mind game program determines that the picture is necessary--it can just go take it." These hyper-personalized mind game experiences are similar to the latest ideas surrounding the Metaverse. The Metaverse is an unclear vision of cyberspace where individuals can interact in virtual reality, mixed reality, or augmented reality in a new computing paradigm. Facebook was so excited about the Metaverse that the company announced it was going to invest $10B in building out its virtual reality platform and changed its name to Meta Platforms, Inc. Matthew Ball has covered the Metaverse since 2018 and has penned his own definition: "The Metaverse is a massively scaled and interoperable network of real-time rendered 3D virtual worlds which can be experienced synchronously and persistently by an effectively unlimited number of users with an individual sense of presence, and with continuity of data, such as identity, history, entitlements, objects, communications, and payments." This is reminiscent of the world we explored in our September 2019 book, Ready Player One, and somewhat similar to the 1990s promise of the information superhighway. It will be interesting to see how the Metaverse develops in the coming years.
Anonymity on the Internet. As Ender continues his training at Battle School, Peter and Valentine hatch a plot to create division throughout the world. The two decide the best way to take over the world as young, intelligent children is to write blog posts under a pseudonym and gain a mass following, eventually exercising their political influence. To avoid suspicion, Peter and Valentine switch emotional positions and take on the roles of historical figures aligning with their viewpoints. Peter becomes John Locke, a liberal philosopher, and inventor of the Social Contract, while Valentine becomes Demosthenes, an Athenian hellbent on inciting a war against Macedonia. While the idea of two teenage children starting war by writing on the internet is comical now, the specter might have been possible in the pre-mass internet era of 1985, the year Ender was published. This also raises the contentious shield of anonymity offered by the internet. While some argue that complete anonymity could mean the end of rational society, others say that anonymity must be preserved. This concept of anonymity is extended further in the over-hyped decentralized, crypto/web3 world of the future, where 15-word recovery phrases might become the norm for ultimate secrecy. Internet security and anonymity are likely to evolve if we move to a decentralized computing world - whether this is good or bad remains a matter of view.
Technology and Governments. The International Force (IF) is a space army designed by the world to fight against the evil Buggers. The surprising thing about this International Force is how it unifies different governments: "Val, it was bound to happen. Right now there's a vast international fleet and army in existence, with American hegemony. When the bugger wars are over, all that power will vanish, because it's all built on fear of the buggers. And suddenly we'll look around and discover that all the old alliances are gone, dead and gone, except one, the Warsaw Pact." The Warsaw Pact was the agreement between the Soviet Union and several neighboring states following the creation of NATO. Funnily enough, the Warsaw Pact disbanded in 1991 with the fall of the Soviet Union, six years following the publication of Ender's Game. After Ender defeats the Buggers, the world immediately descends into political chaos until Peter comes to power. A once unified world with incredible technology like real-time technological communication through the Ansible is now torn apart by politics. These events bring up the broader role of government in the technological landscape. As we saw earlier this year, global non-US tech superpowers like Bytedance (owner of Tiktok) can cause immense political tension. Furthermore, companies like Taiwan Semiconductor (TSMC), that offer a unique product in a politically contentious region can even provoke the potential for war. Technology enables globalization while also raising the question of who owns non-physical products - the government, a company, or the world?

Business Themes

self-managed teams - four types of teams-1.png

Lonely at the Top. Card paints a world where the entire universe's future lies on children's shoulders. Ender becomes commander of the International Fleet, put in the challenging position as leader of older kids. He has to generate empathy while maintaining command. But Ender is just an intelligent child, and throughout the book, he finds himself in bad situations. He eventually grows to be the leader of his launch group and then the leader of his own Dragon Army. As Ender gains in stature, he loses touch with his friends. In one instance, he fears battle school enemies might jump him in the hallway and chastises Petra when she asks him to chat: "'Petra, if you had actually taken me aside just now, there are about a dozen boys following along who would have taken me in the corridor. Can you tell me you didn't notice them?' Suddenly her face flushed. "No. I didn't. How can you think I did? Don't you know who your friends are?" Many CEOs describe that the job can be lonely because you are naturally the final decision-maker. Even as a young child, Ender was forced to become a leader and suffered the mental instability of the job.
Sending a Message. The IF chooses Ender because he is a mix of his two siblings, Peter, who represents extreme violence, and Valentine, who represents empathy. Violence is a recurring theme throughout the book - personal violence between individuals, violence between nations, and violence between civilizations (humans and buggers). In two dramatic sequences, older boys try to corner an unsuspecting Ender. Ender uses his brains to evade an attack but severely injures the attacker to send a message: "They were all wondering if he was dead. Ender, however, was trying to figure out a way to forestall vengeance. To keep them from taking him in a pack tomorrow. I have to win this now, and for all time, or I'll fight it every day and it will get worse and worse. Ender knew the unspoken rules of manly warfare, even though he was only six." Ender thought he needed to message all of his potential attackers. However, these beatings weigh on him constantly, and he spends the rest of his life regretting them. The violent nature of these attacks is reprehensible and difficult to compare to the business world. But it does raise how some executives act with emotion to humiliate or denigrate employees. Recently the CEO of online mortgage startup Better.com fired 900 people over a zoom video call. Beyond the act, the message it sends to employees is even worse. These events can follow executives, with media coverage continuing for over five years after the event itself. Actions send messages. They should be taken with caution when emotion or retaliation is involved.
Self-Managed Teams. Ender is a tactical magician and completely changes the Battle Game. Ender's approach is novel: "He had the army drill in eight-man toon maneuvers and four-man half-toons, so that at a single command, his army could be assigned as many as ten separate maneuvers and carry them out at once. No army had ever fragmented itself like that before, but Ender was not planning to do anything that had been done before, either. Most armies practiced mass maneuvers, performed strategies. Ender had none. Instead, he trained his toon leaders to use their small units effectively in achieving limited goals. Unsupported, alone, on their own initiative." This approach is called Self-Managed Teams. The autonomy offered by allowing individuals to manage themselves gives extreme ownership to employees. Self-Managed teams work well in places with repeated work, where employees trust each other and have high self-awareness. This exciting concept has worked well in several businesses, including Facebook and Google.

Dig Deeper

December 2020 - Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? (Blade Runner) by Phillip K. Dick

This month we read the classic sci-fi novel, Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? The book follows Rick Deckard, a bounty hunter searching out android robots who are pretending to be human beings. Along the journey, the reader is asked to consider: what does it mean to be alive? Philip K. Dick was a crazy sci-fi writer, producing many books and stories that became famous like The Man in the High Castle, Minority Report, and Total Recall. Although his writing career was prolific, Dick was a troubled individual. He was a heavy drug user, he married five times, he experienced drug-induced “paranormal activities” and he was physically abusive to at least two of his wives. While

Tech Themes

The common, modern depiction of a Turing Test

Are you an android? In 1950, British computer scientist Alan Turing conceived of the Turing Test, a hypothetical test to determine whether a machine can display intelligent behavior. Turing asked the question, “Can machines think?” and attempted to define a test whereby a human might be tricked into believing a machine was human. The test design is fairly complex but involves a human asking written questions to a machine in another room. If the machine can convince the interrogator that it’s human, then machines can “think.” This Turing test is mirrored in the Voigt-Kampff test used throughout the book. It’s unclear if the test works, and Rick Deckard almost misdiagnoses Rachel in the book's early parts. At the end of the book, the test is turned on its head, with Rick impersonating John Isidore (another human), trying to convince machines (in another room) to let him in. This role-reversal and the questioning of who is an android happens throughout the novel - at times, Rick, Phil Resh, and Harry Bryant might all be androids. These questions are the centerpiece of sci-fi lore. They are also explored in a similar style in the famous movie Ghost in The Shell, where people have now have some organs and limbs replaced by electric parts. When a cyber-attacker named the Puppet Master takes over the machine network of technological parts, it’s unclear who is human, who is an android, and who is possessed by the Puppet Master. In the video game world, this idea has also recently been explored in Detroit: Become Human. In the game, which is set up in choose-your-own-adventure style, players can play as humans or androids and choose whether they stay in character or break out of their controlled, android state. The idea of an interrogator or bounty hunter snooping out rogue machines has been explored across books, film, and video games. As technology has become more prevalent in our lives, the cultural mediums may have changed, but the classic philosophical question - what does it mean to be alive? - remains.
Predicting the future. The Blade Runner movie is famously set in Los Angeles, 2019, while the book is set in 1992 in San Francisco. The book itself was written in 1968, and the movie Blade Runner debuted 14 years later in 1982. In 2019, Blade Runner experienced a comic resurgence as its dark, bleak futuristic society of flying cars, fully intelligent artificial beings, and international space travel never happened. Today, predictions of computing and artificial intelligence abound. In his original Imitation Game paper, Alan Turing made one of the most famous AI predictions: “I believe that in about fifty years’ time it will be possible to programme computers, with a storage capacity of about 10^9, to make them play the imitation game so well that an average interrogator will not have more than 70 percent, chance of making the right identification after five minutes of questioning.” It’s tough to know if this prediction came true (other than the 10^9 part because that is only 1 GB), with some places claiming to have built algorithms that beat the Turing Test. Interestingly, one common theme emerges about these computing predictions - both experts and non-experts typically predict about 15-25 years out. In the Innovators, Walter Issacson posited that this was enough time to allow people to engage in imaginative thinking. Roy Amara, co-founder of the Institute for the Future, probably put it best: “We tend to overestimate the effect of a technology in the short run and underestimate the effect in the long run.” How long run is the long run, though? As John Maynard Keynes proclaimed: “In the long run we are all dead. Economists set themselves too easy, too useless a task if, in tempestuous seasons, they can only tell us that when the storm is long past the ocean is flat again.” It is seriously hard to estimate the combination of changing technologies and infrastructures, which unlock completely new and cost-effective ways of building things. Will we have self-driving cars in 20 years? Will we have Artificial General Intelligence? Will we have quantum computing? I have no idea.
Technology and nature. One theme repeatedly explored throughout the novel is this balance or tension between technology and nature. World War Terminus has caused a layer of radioactive dust to fall over the world, killing animal life and changing the environment. Mechanical animals are the norm, and Rick dreams about procuring a real horse, ostrich, or goat one day. He regularly checks his Sidney’s Animal & Fowl Catalogue like a stockbroker checking the latest price change. A real animal is significantly more expensive than a mechanical version, despite it being nearly impossible to figure out whether an animal is real or fake. This mirror’s the book's whole premise - a real human is more important and valuable than an Android despite increasingly small differences between Androids and humans. Rick realizes this at the end of the book: “The spider Mercer gave the chickenhead, Isidore; it probably was artificial, too. But it doesn't matter. The electric things have their lives, too. Paltry as those lives are." Technology and nature have a tradeoff in today’s world as well. Cloud computing is certainly energy-intensive, but according to the companies that run those clouds (like Google Cloud or Microsoft Azure), it is significantly less intensive than having companies run their own data centers. Beyond the environmental impact, the behavior of nature is something to consider when operating a data center. A few years ago, Facebook data centers went down when a Snake chewed through a switchboard and took down all services. In 2014, a shark bit through an underwater Google fiber cable, and in 2012 a squirrel took down a Yahoo data center. Animals, technology, and nature are constantly interacting, sometimes in unexpected ways.

Business Themes

Status seeking and the growth of e-commerce. In the battle to achieve status, real animals are a highly sought after status symbol. Early on in the book, Rick engages in a jealous conversation over his neighbor’s real horse: “‘Ever thought of selling your horse?’ Rick asked. He wished to god he had a horse, in fact any animal.” After revealing that his sheep was electric, Rick’s neighbor kindly remarks that he won’t tell the other people in the apartment complex, suggesting that if people knew Rick had an electric sheep (rather than a real one), they would look down on him. While this interaction seems weird, it parallels so many interactions people have today. Vance Packard offered a description of “status seekers” in 1959: “People who are continually straining to surround themselves with visible evidence of the superior rank they are claiming.” As general consumption and wealth rose after World-War II in the US, luxury goods became more attainable for more classes. Globalization of supply chains also increased this trend. When commerce moved online, new shopping styles and behaviors emerged. E-commerce purchases can frequently replace feelings and there is even a psychological disorder caused by excessive purchasing: Buying-shopping disorder (BSD) is characterized by extreme preoccupations with and craving for buying/shopping and by irresistible and identity-seeking urges to possess consumer goods. Patients with BSD buy more consumer goods than they can afford, and those are neither needed nor frequently used. The excessive purchasing is primarily used to regulate emotions, e.g. to get pleasure, relief from negative feelings, or coping with self-discrepancy.” Dick may be signaling that humans seek status and importance compared to their reference groups, regardless of setting or what indicates that status to others, whether it be an expensive handbag or a goat.
Buy goat now, pay-later. 2020 saw the emergence of buy-now, pay-later (BNPL) vendors like Affirm, Klarna, and Afterpay. These companies typically offer zero-interest loans to consumers and get paid a 5% merchant fee for increasing purchases at e-commerce stores. The stores (like Peloton for example) increase sales and the consumers benefit from not having to pay a significant upfront payment. The other way these companies make money is by charging interest payments on specific types of purchases (likely where the merchant doesn’t want to give away a fee). These interest rates can be really, really high - averaging around 10-30% depending on the purchase. This is not a new concept and the idea of payday loans at predatorily high-interest rates has been around for over 30 years. Luckily, the purchases that these BNPL providers are financing tend to not be really high-value products, but it’s still concerning that some people are buying things without understanding the true value they will have to pay in interest. When Rick purchases a real goat, after killing three androids, he finances it, paying $3,000 upfront and entering into a three-year payment contract. Rick’s wife Iran is outraged at the cost of the goat: "‘What are the monthly payments on the goat?’ She held out her hand; reflexively he got out the contract which he had signed, passed it to her. ‘That much,’ she said in a thin voice. ‘The interest; good god — the interest alone. And you did this because you were depressed. Not as a surprise for me, as you originally said.” With BNPL providers now securitizing these consumer loans and selling them off to banks, I wonder if we will see any new regulation come to bear for the benefit of consumers. If people are not careful, they could be locked into long contracts with significant interest over time.
Two case studies in electric animals. Electric animals have actually been invented and while they may not be the equivalent of Goddard from Jimmy Neutron yet, they are pretty funny and interesting case studies. Sony released the AIBO dog in 1999 after many years of research. The original robot dog cost $2,100 (~$3,500 in today’s dollars) and sold about 65,000 units. The programmable software allowed the dogs to be used in a variety of situations including an AI soccer world cup. The initial popularity of the dogs waned, and price wars with new rivals caused sales to decline. In 2006, the AIBO dog was discontinued. In 2018, it made a resurgence and is now a barking flexible model that you can pet, play games with, and feed. Another tale of odd mechanic animals is Boston Dynamics. The company that spun out of MIT in 1992 produced massive quadruped animals including one called BigDog, that was capable of balancing, walking up-hill, and carrying significant amounts of equipment. The Company had trouble selling products though and was acquired by Google in 2013 for an undisclosed sum. This came at a time when Google was pushing heavily into robotics with Google Glass and what would become Waymo - they literally titled this Project Replicant (the name used for Android in the Blade Runner film). After some more years of underperformance, Google sold Boston Dynamics to Softbank in 2017. After years of development, the company finally released a product to consumers for a whopping $75,000. The dog is still pretty creepy and comes without a real face, unlike the Aibo. In 2020, it was announced that Hyundai had acquired an 80% stake in the business at a $1.1B valuation. We are still years away from having electric animals that mimic real-life animals and that may be a good thing.

Dig Deeper

May 2020 - Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy by Douglas Adams

We want to recognize the craziness of the world today and the saddening police brutality and systemic racism that continues to occur in the US. This month we opted for a fiction book that may provide a minor break from that current, depressing reality. We want to acknowledge that our reality is messed up, and as a book club we are committed to reading more books about diversity in tech and more books written by a diverse set of authors.

Tech Themes

The Computer knows the answer. There is an overwhelming feeling in society today, that the computer should be able to tell us the answer. Predictive models are everywhere, from personalized AI workflows to sports gambling. Society has become accustomed to the idea that computers will solve problems for us. Interestingly, the novel portrays technology in the opposite light. Marvin, the robot on Zaphod Beeblebrox’s ship is so knowledgeable that even the most complex task seems meaninglessly easy. As a result, Marvin is constantly depressed. Deep Thought, the most powerful computer in history, takes seven million years to come up with an answer to the question of what life is all about. The simplistic forty-two answer, prompts the crowd to ask what the question was to which the answer is forty-two. The computer suggests that earth will provide that question. These examples somewhat reverse the expectations of technology to the reader. We normally think of technology as providing the answer, simplifying our lives and dehumanizing us. At the end of the story it is not Marvin’s heroism that saves the crew from being killed by the Blagulon Kappa cops who are after the Heart of Gold, it is his depression. When Marvin seizes control of the cops computer and explains his life-view, they commit suicide. In these instances, the role of technology is reversed - it is emotion and human nature that can help save the world and provide the answers to the universe.
Not so obvious, Space Travel and Towels. “A towel, it says, is about the most massively useful thing an interstellar hitchhiker can have.” Something so simple as a towel - which seems relatively unimportant in everyday life - is an absolute necessity for space travel and hitchhiking through the galaxy. Frequently throughout technological history, the simple and unimportant things are overlooked in favor of tackling more complex problems and solutions. The largest data breach in history occurred when Equifax overlooked an expired certificate. During early development of the ENIAC, one of the first computing machines, software was looked at as unimportant and was relegated to early female programmers. Little did these sexist hardware programmers realize that software would become the most important aspect of computing. When the first iPhone released, Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer laughed at the the device, saying it was too expensive and unable to cater to business customers because it didn’t have a keyboard. The incredibly sad, failed launch of space shuttle Challenger was due to cold temperatures causing rubber joint rings to become too stiff for appropriate sealing. Sometimes the value of a technology or a towel is not inherently obvious.
The Guide, the Whole Earth Catalog and the Internet. “The reason why it was published in the form of a micro sub meson electronic component is that if it were printed in normal book form, an interstellar hitchhiker would require several inconveniently large buildings to carry it around in.” The Hitchhiker’s Guide to The Galaxy is a massive electronic guide to help hitchhikers move throughout space. This interestingly mirrors the current state of the internet, which didn’t exist when Douglas Adams wrote Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy in the early 70s. Prior to the internet, this type of alternative information could be found in the Whole Earth Catalog, a famous magazine that Steve Jobs once called “Google in paperback form, thirty-five years before Google came along.” The Whole Earth Catalog was created by Stewart Brand, a famous writer and technologist, who actually participated with Douglas Englebart in the Mother of All Demos, which featured the introduction of the mouse and video conferencing. Brand wanted a way to publish material that wouldn’t be found in traditional textbooks, including product reviews of the latest technology. When the internet was starting to launch, Brand created The WELL (Whole Earth ‘Lectronic Link) to continue to provide interesting alternative articles and essays. The WELL is credited with being one of the first internet forums, which was originally accessed via dial-up bulletin board system. The internet today very much mirrors the Hitchhiker’s guide to the galaxy: its content is enormous, it isn’t necessarily factual (the Guide is not completely factual either, but based on experience), and its content spans all possible information needed to survive. On top of that, the packaging is described as suspiciously similar to modern smartphones: “He also had a device which looked rather like a largish electronic calculator. This had about a hundred tiny flat press buttons and a screen about four inches square on which any one of a million ‘pages’ could be summoned at a moment's notice.” The internet and mobile computing have come a long way in 50 years; it will be great to watch what happens in the next 50!

Business Themes

StrategyTowardsIndependance_May2020_YoleDeveloppement.png.jpg

The Business of Space: SpaceX / Virgin Galactic. Elon Musk and Chamath Palihapitiya are outspoken, visionary billionaires. Elon has an incredible track record of under-delivering but still exceeding most people’s wildest expectations. Chamath was an early employee at Facebook and is now a part owner of the Golden State Warriors. He is CEO of a VC-firm turned “technological holding company” and the creator of three public SPACs, one of which now represents Virgin Galactic. A SPAC or Specialty Purpose Acquisition Company is a blank-check company with no commercial operations. A SPAC is normally led by experts in a specific space like software or real estate and these executives raise money to acquire a company. The money raised in an IPO sits in an interest bearing account until the blank-check company has found a company to acquire. If no deal is completed after two years, the SPAC will give money back to their investors. Chamath purchased 49% of Richard Branson's Virgin Galactic space company in 2019. Space is impossibly big and its natural to think that someone who can develop the technology to unlock that vastness to humans would also unlock a fortune. As the Guide puts it: “‘Space,’ it says, ‘is big. Really big. You just won’t believe how vastly, hugely, mindbogglingly big it is. I mean, you may think it’s a long way down the road to the chemist’s, but that’s just peanuts to space.’” But the business of space is in its earliest days. SpaceX relies almost completely on government contracted work which means the company needs an incredible amount of funding to survive because of the capital investment and the uncertain, non-recurring nature of these space contracts. Interestingly, the development of early commercial air travel, in the 1920’s, also had a similar funding issue, and it was up to the Guggenheim family, rich from mining profits, to set up a fund to exclusively contribute to the development of Western Air Express, the world’s first commercial airliner. Virgin Galactic is taking a piece out of Tesla’s playbook by selling future space rides ahead of any commercial launch. Public markets investors including reddit’s wallstreetbets community is piling into Virgin Galactic at the literal moonshot risk of it becoming the space company (Income statement above). Space has always been a billionaire passion, the question remains - can it be a business?
Moore’s Law and Murphy’s Law. Murphy’s law states: “Anything that can go wrong, will go wrong.” Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy explores this notion repeatedly as Arthur continually finds himself in unbelievably bad circumstances; his house is demolished, his planet is destroyed, he is captured by Vogons, and sure-death missles approach the ship as the crew descends on Magarathea. Arthur continues to survive these dangers with the help of the improbability drive, which the book states is a “a wonderful new method of crossing interstellar distances in a few seconds; without all that tedious mucking about in hyperspace. As the Improbability Drive reaches infinite improbability, it passes through every conceivable point in every conceivable universe almost simultaneously. In other words, you're never sure where you'll end up or even what species you'll be when you get there. It's therefore important to dress accordingly.” In comparison to Murphy’s law, Moore’s Law is the idea that computing power doubles every 18 months. A 2006 Economist article explained Moore’s Law as the opposite of Murphy’s Law: “But his law seems safe for at least another decade—or two to three chip generations—which is as far as he has ever dared to look into the future. As things are made at scales approaching individual atoms, he says, there will surely be limitations. Then again, the law has often met obstacles that appeared insurmountable, before soon surmounting them. In that sense, Mr Moore says, he now sees his law as more beautiful than he had realised. “Moore's Law is a violation of Murphy's Law. Everything gets better and better.” While Moore’s Law has surely reached its current limitations, the question remains where do chips go from here? Some have posited that chips will push towards function specific hardware or purpose built for specific computing tasks like NVIDIA’s graphics cards. The space is large and complex - with companies like Apple licensing ARM technology to build their famous A13 chip while other companies have focused on specific parts of the value chain like TSMC. A big question that still remains is how cloud companies will scale hardware to meet continuing demand from customers. Arthur Dent, like Elon Musk, continues to benefit from infinite improbability - maybe quantum computing is the only way to know if Elon will succeed and what happens next in chip design.
Mentorship. Slartibarfast is a wise, old, planet creator who is plopped into the story to provide Arthur with answers to so many incredible questions. Slartibartfast explains the creation of earth and the interaction with Deep Thought. The interactions between Arthur and Slartibartfast are somewhat akin to traditional business mentorship - when you have none of the answers or you have preconceived ideas of how everything came to be, a mentor can quickly dispel your ideas and provide deep answers. Mentorship has been popular in Silicon Valley, with Bill Campbell mentoring Steve Jobs and several others. Bill was also instrumental in several decisions Ben Horowitz contemplated as he took Opsware through its spinout and sale of its managed services division. Mentors help change perspective and provide guidance.

Dig Deeper

December 2019 - The Moon is a Harsh Mistress by Robert A. Heinlein

This futuristic, anti-establishment thriller is one of Elon Musk’s favorite books. While Heinlein’s novel can drag on with little action, The Moon is a Harsh Mistress presents an interesting war story and predicts several technological revolutions.

Tech Themes

Mike, the self-aware computer and IBM. Mycroft Holmes, Heinlein’s self-aware, artificially intelligent computer is a friendly, funny and focused companion to Manny, Wyoh and Prof throughout the novel. Mike’s massive hardware construction is analogous to the way companies are viewing Artificial Intelligence today. Mike’s AI is more closely related to Artificial General Intelligence, which imagines a machine that can go beyond the standard Turing Test, with further abilities to plan, learn, communicate in natural language and act on objects. The 1960s were filled with predictions of futuristic robots and machines. Ideas were popularized not only in books like The Moon is a Harsh Mistress but also in films like 2001: A Space Odyssey, where the intelligent computer, HAL 9000, attempts to overthrow the crew. In 1965, Herbert Simon, a noble prize winner, exclaimed: “machines will be capable, within twenty years, of doing any work a man can do.” As surprising as it may seem today, the dominant technology company of the 1960’s was IBM, known for its System/360 model. Heinlein even mentions Thomas Watson and IBM at Mike’s introduction: “Mike was not official name; I had nicknamed him for Mycroft Holmes, in a story written by Dr. Watson before he founded IBM. This story character would just sit and think--and that's what Mike did. Mike was a fair dinkum thinkum, sharpest computer you'll ever meet.” Mike’s construction is similar to that of present day IBM Watson, who’s computer was able to win Jeopardy, but has struggled to gain traction in the market. IBM and Heinlein approached the computer development in a similar way, Heinlein foresaw a massive computer with tons of hardware linked into it: “They kept hooking hardware into him--decision-action boxes to let him boss other computers, bank on bank of additional memories, more banks of associational neural nets, another tubful of twelve-digit random numbers, a greatly augmented temporary memory. Human brain has around ten-to-the tenth neurons. By third year Mike had better than one and a half times that number of neuristors.” This is the classic IBM approach – leverage all of the hardware possible and create a massive database of query-able information. This actually does work well for information retrieval like Jeopardy, but stumbles precariously on new information and lack of data, which is why IBM has struggled with Watson applications to date.
Artificial General Intelligence. Mike is clearly equipped with artificial general intelligence (AGI); he has the ability to securely communicate in plain language, retrieve any of the world’s information, see via cameras and hear via microphones. As discussed above, Heinlein’s construction of Mike is clearly hardware focused, which makes sense considering the book was published in the sixties, before software was considered important. In contrast to the 1960s, today, AGI is primarily addressed from an algorithmic, software angle. One of the leading research institutions (excluding the massive tech companies) is OpenAI, an organization who’s mission is: “To ensure that artificial general intelligence (AGI)—by which we mean highly autonomous systems that outperform humans at most economically valuable work—benefits all of humanity.” OpenAI was started by several people including Elon Musk and Sam Altman, founder of Y Combinator, a famous startup incubator based in Silicon Valley. OpenAI just raised $1 billion from Microsoft to pursue its artificial algorithms and is likely making the most progress when it comes to AGI. The organization has released numerous modules that allow developers to explore the wide-ranging capabilities of AI, from music creation, to color modulation. But software alone is not going to be enough to achieve full AGI. OpenAI has acknowledged that the largest machine learning training runs have been run on increasingly more hardware: “Of course, the use of massive compute sometimes just exposes the shortcomings of our current algorithms.” As we discussed before (companies are building their own hardware for this purpose, link to building their own hardware), and the degradation of Moore’s Law imposes a serious threat to achieving full Artificial General Intelligence.
Deep Learning, Adam Selene, and Deep Fakes. Heinlein successfully predicted machine’s ability to create novel images. As the group plans to take the rebellion public, Mike is able to create a depiction of Adam Selene that can appear on television and be the face of the revolution: “We waited in silence. Then screen showed neutral gray with a hint of scan lines. Went black again, then a faint light filled middle and congealed into cloudy areas light and dark, ellipsoid. Not a face, but suggestion of face that one sees in cloud patterns covering Terra. It cleared a little and reminded me of pictures alleged to be ectoplasm. A ghost of a face. Suddenly firmed and we saw "Adam Selene." Was a still picture of a mature man. No background, just a face as if trimmed out of a print. Yet was, to me, "Adam Selene." Could not he anybody else.” Image generation and manipulation has long been a hot topic among AI researchers. The research frequently leverages a technique called Deep Learning, which is a play on classically used Artificial Neural Networks. A 2012 landmark paper from the University of Toronto student Ilya Sutskever, who went on to be a founder at OpenAI, applied deep learning to the problem of image classification with incredible success. Deep learning and computer vision have been inseparable ever since. One part of research focuses on a video focused image superimposition technique called Deep Fakes, which became popular earlier this year. As shown here, these videos are essentially merging existing images and footage with a changing facial structure, which is remarkable and scary at the same time. Deep fakes are gaining so much attention that even the government is focused on learning more about them. Heinlein was early to the game, imaging a computer could create a novel image. I can only imagine how he’d feel about Deep Fakes.

Business Themes

Video Conferencing. Manny and the rest of the members of the revolution communicate through encrypted phone conversations and video conferences. While this was certainly ahead of its time, video conferencing was first imagined in the late 1800s. Despite a clear demand for the technology, it took until the late 2000s arguably, to reach appoint where mass video communication was easily accessible for businesses (Zoom Video) and individuals (FaceTime, Skype, etc.) This industry has constantly evolved and there are platforms today that offer both secure chat and video such as Microsoft Teams and Cisco Webex. The entire industry is a lesson in execution. The idea was dreamed up so long ago, but it took hundreds of years and multiple product iterations to get to a de-facto standard in the market. Microsoft purchased Skype in 2011 for $8.5B, the same year that Eric Yuan founded Zoom. This wasn’t Microsoft’s first inroads into video either, in 2003, Microsoft bought Placeware and was supposed to overtake the market. But they didn’t and Webex continued to be a major industry player before getting acquired by Cisco. Over time Skype popularity has waned, and now, Microsoft Teams has a fully functioning video platform separate from Skype – something that Webex did years ago. Markets are constantly in a state of evolution, and its important to see what has worked well. Skype and Zoom both succeeded by appealing to free users, Skype initially focused on free consumers, and Zoom focused on free users within businesses. WebEx has always been enterprise focused but they had to be, because bandwidth costs were too high to support a video platform. Teams will go to market as a next-generation alternate/augmentation of Outlook; it will be interesting to see what happens going forward.
Privacy and Secure Communication. As part of the revolution’s communication, a secure, isolated message system is created whereby not only are conversations fully encrypted and undetected by authorities but also individuals are unable to speak with more than two others in their revolution tree. Today, there are significant concerns about secure communication – people want it, but they also do not. Facebook has declared that they will implement end to end encryption despite warnings from the government not to do so. Other mobile applications like Telegram and Signal promote secure messaging and are frequently used by reporters for anonymous tips. While encryption is beneficial for those messaging, it does raise concerns about who has access to what information. Should a company have access to secure messages? Should the government have access to secure messages? Apple has always stayed strong in its privacy declaration, but has had its own missteps. This is a difficult question and the solution must be well thought out, taking into account unintended consequences of sweeping regulation in any direction.
Conglomerates. LuNoHo Co is the conglomerate that the revolution utilized to build a massive catapult and embezzle funds. While Mike’s microtransaction financial fraud is interesting (“But bear in mind that an auditor must assume that machines are honest.”), the design of LuNoHo Co. which is described as part bank, part engineering firm, and part oil and gas exploitation firm, interestingly addresses the conventional business wisdom of the times. In the 1960s, coming out of World War II, conglomerates began to really take hold across many developing nations. The 1960s were a period of low interest rates, which allowed firms to perform leveraged buyouts of other companies (using low interest loans), sometimes in a completely unrelated set of industries. Activision was once part of Vivendi, a former waste management, energy, construction, water and property conglomerate. The rationale for these moves was often that a much bigger organization could centralize general costs like accounting, finance, legal and other costs that touched every aspect of the business. However, when interest rates rose in the late 70s and early 80s, several conglomerate profits fell, and the synergies promised at the outset of the deal turned out to be more difficult to realize than initially assumed. Conglomerates are incredibly popular in Asia, often times supported by the government. In 2013, McKinsey estimated: “Over the past decade, conglomerates in South Korea accounted for about 80 percent of the largest 50 companies by revenues. In India, the figure is a whopping 90 percent. Meanwhile, China’s conglomerates (excluding state-owned enterprises) represented about 40 percent of its largest 50 companies in 2010, up from less than 20 percent a decade before.” Softbank, the famous Japanese conglomerate and creator of the vision fund, was originally a shrink-wrap software distributor but now is part VC and part Telecommunications provider. We’ve discussed the current state of Chinese internet conglomerates, Alibaba and Tencent who each own several different business lines. Over the coming years, as internet access in Asia grows more pervasive and the potential for economic downturn increases, it will be interesting to see if these conglomerates break apart and focus on their core businesses.

Dig Deeper

September 2019 - Ready Player One by Ernest Cline

Ernest Cline’s magical world of virtual reality is explores a potential new medium of communication through an excellent heroic tale.

Tech Themes

1. Wide-ranging applicability and use cases of Virtual Reality. Although the novel was written in 2011, Ernest Cline does an incredible job of detailing the complex and numerous use cases of VR throughout the novel. Cline’s 18 year old main character Wade Watts attends school via VR, where you can have a limitless number of students all learn from the same teacher. Beyond that, different worlds and galaxies are easily conjured up with different themes, time periods and technology taking learning and experience to another level: Wade spends time playing old video games in an effort to unlock certain clues about James Halliday, Wade re-enacts all of Matthew Broderick’s part in the movie War Games in an effort to unlock one of the keys, Aech and Wade frequently hang out in the Basement, a re-created 1980’s recreational room with vintage magazines and game consoles. All of these distinct use cases – education, gaming, social networking, and entertainment – are the promise of Virtual Reality. There is a long way to go before that promise is met.

2. The intersection of the online/offline world. As James Halliday writes in Anorak’s Almanac: “Going outside is highly overrated.” Ready Player One does a great job of exploring the conflation of the online and offline worlds. The book weaves together experiences from this intersection into critical moments of the book including Wade’s escape from the Stacks and his imprisonment by IOI. While there is a tangible feeling that online is the much preferred experience for all the reasons discussed above, it’s the offline in-person events that truly shape the heroic ending of the book. This serves as a reminder that the OASIS is very much a virtual reality and explores the need for in-person human connection. Ironically, this is something Halliday sorely missed out on as shown through his unrequited love for Ogden Morrow’s (co-creator of the OASIS) wife, Kira. As big companies move into our homes through Google Homepods, Amazon Echos, Facebook Portals, the human connection element needs to be maintained.

3. The ability to disguise your identity online. “In the OASIS, you could become whomever and whatever you wanted to be, without ever revealing your true identity, because your anonymity was guaranteed.” This quote about the OASIS is largely true of today’s Internet. Through private browsing, Virtual Private Networks, avoiding Google and ad-tagging websites, people are able to stay anonymous online already. But what the OASIS does in addition, is allow you to modify not only your back-story, but also how you appear to others, something that is very important in VR. While there is no question that Wade, Art3mis and Aech are able to avoid insecurities by masking their identities, eventually those insecurities are revealed, albeit with little consequence. Given the myriad of leaks and breaches in the last few years (Yahoo, Facebook, DoorDash, etc.), as the VR ecosystem continues to grow, increasing amounts of privacy will be needed to maintain anonymity.

Business themes

1. What is the dominant revenue model in VR? The evil villains at Innovative Online Industries (IOI) and their army of sixers have tried several hostile takeover attempts to acquire Halliday’s Gregarious Simulations Systems in order to convert it to a paid user model. IOI is the world’s largest internet service provider and just like other three letter named tech behemoths (cough, IBM, cough), fits the classic evil corporation vibe. Dismissing the potential business and technology conflicts (the world’s largest ISP is probably critical in delivering the OASIS throughout the world), its interesting to theorize what the dominant revenue model of VR may be. Facebook recently launched its VR world to complement its Oculus devices and there have been varied attempts to launch similar software worlds like Rec Room. The big discovery Google made early on was that advertising would be the business model of the web. Facebook copied this as it created social networking and as devices transitioned from desktop to mobile, and image to video, advertising continued to be the dominant mode of content monetization. Is there any reason to think VR will be any different? Potentially. The current dominant model for video gaming is subscriber based, freemium (paying for enhanced abilities, character changes, etc.) or single purchase. While there is no reason these ideas can’t be combined with advertising, the idea of a multi-world VR landscape may reduce some of the targeted ROI you receive from very specific ad-targeting on Instagram and Google today. In a limitless world, advertising to specific people will be difficult. Beyond that, porting the mish-mash of complex technologies used in today’s advertising landscape would add even more challenge.

2. The BIG, evil tech corporation. IOI is the quintessential evil technology company. As the world’s largest ISP, IOI could be a reference to Comcast, which is the United States’ largest ISP and often referenced as one of the most hated companies. Comcast, like other ISPs is always facing the challenge of serving millions of subscribers but unlike other companies, they are monopolistic in certain areas where they are the only viable provider for internet, allowing them to raise prices and treat customers poorly. The big, evil technology corporation cliché has been around for a long time and today’s largest tech companies have all spent sometime being that cliché. This dynamic can arise for many reasons. At Amazon, it’s the continued alienation of open source communities, the anti-competitive behavior around its search algorithm and the smothering of small vendors on its marketplace. Facebook and Google have both faced privacy concerns. Google has been sued for manipulating search on mobile devices. Microsoft was sued for anti-trust issues over browsers. As startups begin to dominate their core businesses, unless they continue innovating, they begin acting defensively to maintain their leading position. Facebook feature copied Snapchat stories almost immediately after they came out. IBM had a book written on them in the 1980s claiming they were anticompetitive. There is a reason corporate communications (WeWork lol) are so important and maintaining the image of a positive change for good. Every major technology company has spent time as the evil one, some have just spent more time than others.

3. Difficulty in creating VR applications. Ready Player One stoked a lot interest in the promise of VR, but the actual implementation is incredibly difficult with the hardware and software we have available as tools today. Moore’s law is slowing and some computer scientists have suggested specific chips to address the demands of newer technologies like Artificial Intelligence, Virtual Reality and Deep Learning. After Facebook acquired Oculus in 2014 for $2.4B, funding continued to flow into VR startups. Magic Leap, the highly secretive and most heavily funded VR startup has raised $2.3B on its own, and after years of development finally released its hardware for over $2,000 per device and its unclear if it makes a profit on any sales yet. More recently, several VR companies have gone bankrupt and laid off employees as product development didn’t reach application or end users before the funding ran out. While the software and hardware continues to improve, a lot still needs to be figured out before VR becomes mainstream.

Dig Deeper

January 2019 - The Martian by Andy Weir

This an epic story of a journey to get home (SPOILER ALERT). The audiobook is incredible and I’d highly recommend it.

Tech Themes

Necessity is the mother of all invention. Constraints breed creativity. In the book, Mark is repeatedly saddled with different and more challenging situations (the Hab, the Rover, communicating, etc.). With each challenge, Mark Watney is forced to come up with inventions in order to survive. It is often the constraints of a situation that create amazing products. Let’s take Dropbox for example, Drew Houston famously wrote the program because he had forgetting his thumb drive on a Chinatown bus from Boston to New York. This also carries to music - each instrument offers a set of possible actions, governed by the overall rules of music. Remember the Marty McFly guitar solo in Back to the Future, nobody was ready for the crazy 80’s solo in the 60’s. Mark Watney, Drew Houston and Jimi Hendrix leveraged available tools in innovative ways out of the necessity of their circumstances.
Resource management. Cash is King and so are potatoes. Throughout the story, Mark refers to his current food circumstances and quickly calculates his estimated number of days remaining. Like Mark, founders of startups should always know when they will be out of money or how much runway they have available. In practice, startups may lose sight of this date for a number of reasons: they lack product-market fit, they scale too fast, or they raise too much money and don’t pay attention to cash contingencies.
Space is hard. After Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin landed on the moon in July 1969, everyone thought commercial space travel would soon arrive. While several billionaires have attempted to get to space: Jeff Bezos with Blue Origin, Richard Branson with Virgin Galactic, and Elon Musk with SpaceX, there hasn’t been a huge boom of space startups many predicted after 1969. The reason space has become a billionaire game is the lack of expected ROI and large amount of capital necessary to build a space business. Beyond that, as exhibited by Rich Purnell/Donald Glover in the Martian, the math needs to be exact and there are so many variables at play with space tech. While VCs have to return money to their investors at the end of a fund, billionaires do not: “Most investors, institutional investors, venture capital investors, or angels are looking for business opportunities that have a demonstrable probability of success.” This was the mindset for many years but recently, with the success of SpaceX and overall great market times for VCs, it has been changing. Investors are realizing these moonshot (pun intended) technologies represent massive opportunity. To that end, space funding has grown significantly in the past couple of years.

Business Themes

Internal politics. Throughout the book, there are several internal tensions between different involved parties including the Jet Propulsion Lab (JPL) and NASA. This comes to a head when Teddy Sanders (Head of NASA) makes the call over Mitch Henderson to not tell the Hermes crew that Mark Watney is still alive. While Teddy argues this is necessary to keep them focused on their mission, Mitch feels like he is lying to his crew. This gets to an interesting business questions which is, how much shared information is best within an organization? On one end of the system you have Netflix, who publishes manager salary information for anyone to view. On the other hand you have Apple, who as discussed previously had four separate teams trying to come up with an iPhone independently. Jason Lemkin argues 90% of information should be shared as a baseline, but it is probably different for different managers and companies.
Positive spin PR. Especially in tech, there is a drive to spin everything as positive PR. From internal company announcements to external marketing, everything is spun to show company XYZ as the best company in the world. Throughout the book, Annie Montrose (NASA’s PR director) is forced to spin each subsequent announcement with a positive twist. She knows the veracity of the situation: “This was going to be rough and Annie knew it. Not only did she have to deliver the biggest mea culpa in NASA’s history, every second of it would be remembered forever. Every movement of her arms, intonation of her voice, and expression of her face would be seen by millions of people over and over again. Not just in the immediate press cycle, but for decades to come.” While this actually is the biggest press release of all time in the book, Tech companies like to think every announcement is like this, opting to consistently give positive remarks despite whatever challenges. As noted here, Elizabeth Holmes has had to do this positive spinning since Theranos has come under fire on some of its practices - obviously in hindsight we know how misleading these announcements were. Another example of this positive spin mentality is this 2014 Memo from Microsoft where 12,500 employees were told they were losing their jobs. The first 10 paragraphs of the letter spell out the new and innovative competitive strategy that Microsoft is undertaking to be competitive in certain domains. It isn’t until you are at paragraph 11, that you realize you may be getting fired. Be wary of PR from tech companies, a lot of it is masking bad news.
Partnerships / working together. After a failed launch on an incredibly short timeline, the US is out of options to save Watney until the Chinese National Space Agency (CSNA) volunteers the Taiyang Shen, the most technologically sophisticated space probe ever designed in China, to fly on the next mission. While this action shows the value of a human life, it also represents how valuable partnerships can be. China yields a consolation prize of having an astronaut join on the mission, but loses out on its planned launch years in the making, however being swept into this global effort could bring even more funding to China’s space program for years to come. If you look at great partnerships in the history of technology you see repeating patterns: increased distribution (Zynga games/Spotify music shareable on the facebook platform), better quality (Yahoo’s search got significantly better when powered by Google), and higher market share (Intel’s partnerships with Apple and Microsoft). While some of these partnerships end up hurting one side more than another (Google/Yahoo), they yield near term success and can help build massive businesses.